69 BEST Tips Fantasy Football 1st Pick (Why)

Fantasy Football 1st Pick - My Very Subjective, Personal Opinion:

The 1st pick is overrated. Sure, you get a superstar, but the pressure to nail every later pick is insane.

I’d rather draft mid-round, build a balanced roster, and avoid the snake-draft drought.

Want to crush your draft no matter your position? Dive into the strategy guide below.

Fantasy Football 1st Pick - Full Picture:

The first pick in fantasy football is a game-changer. It’s the pinnacle of drafting strategy, the starting point of your roster, and a decision that could make or break your season. With so much riding on this choice, it's crucial to analyze every angle — from player performance and positional value to historical trends and expert advice. This comprehensive guide will help you make the most informed decision when it's your turn to draft first.

Lead with a name that turns heads! Check out 5971 fantasy football names that avoid player references. >>>

Why the 1st Pick is Unique

Setting the Tone for Your Draft

The first pick not only gives you access to elite talent but also dictates the rest of your draft strategy. Since your next pick won't come until the second-round swing in snake drafts, selecting the right player is vital. This player must consistently perform and be reliable, as they’ll become the foundation of your success.

Psychological Advantage

Drafting first can have psychological benefits. A strong, high-performing first-round pick can put pressure on other managers, who then scramble to counter your early lead. Additionally, it gives you clarity — you’re securing one of the best players in the game, eliminating the guesswork of waiting for players to fall to you.

Strategies for Choosing Your 1st Pick

Best Player Available (BPA) vs. Roster Needs

When you’re on the clock, debates often arise between selecting the Best Player Available (BPA) or prioritizing based on positional scarcity. At the top of the draft, BPA often reigns supreme.

• BPA Strategy focuses on selecting the most talented and productive player at any position. Historically, running backs and wide receivers dominate this discussion.

• Roster Needs may matter more in the later rounds, but with your first pick, it’s generally better to secure the best all-around asset available.

Positional Value Considerations

Positional value plays a crucial role in a 1st pick strategy. Here’s an analysis of how each position impacts the draft:

• Running Backs

They have traditionally ruled the first overall pick due to the scarcity of elite options and their high touch volume. Consider players who are integral to an offense and can contribute both as runners and receivers. Workhorse running backs are especially coveted.

• Wide Receivers

This position has risen in value in PPR (points per reception) formats. Elite WRs like Justin Jefferson or Ja'Marr Chase not only bring consistency but can dominate a scoring system. They’re often safer picks compared to injury-prone running backs.

• Quarterbacks

Though quarterbacks score the most overall points, drafting one with the first pick is rare in most formats. The abundance of solid QBs available later makes using the first overall selection for this position less appealing unless in superflex leagues.

• Tight Ends

While the gap between elite tight ends and others can be significant, choosing one with the first overall pick is highly unorthodox. Positional depth negates the need to grab a tight end this early.

Make your team name unforgettable with player-inspired ideas! Discover them >>>

The Debate Around Specific Players

Analyzing Top Candidates

Knowing the key contenders for the 1st overall pick helps you narrow your decision. Here are some players who often dominate this conversation:

• Christian McCaffrey (RB)

McCaffrey offers incredible dual-threat ability. He racks up points on the ground and through receiving yards, making him a high-floor, high-ceiling pick. However, his health history can be a concern.

• Justin Jefferson (WR)

Jefferson has proven to be a dominant force, especially in PPR leagues. With his consistent production, big-play ability, and established rapport with his quarterback, he’s an extremely safe and reliable first pick.

• Austin Ekeler (RB)

Ekeler's impact in both rushing and passing games makes him a valuable asset. His PPR value skyrockets given his high reception totals. Still, his workload durability in a long season is a factor to consider.

• Ja’Marr Chase (WR)

With elite explosiveness and a high touchdown upside, Chase is a contender for the 1st overall pick, especially in dynamic and aggressive leagues.

• Bijan Robinson (RB)

Every fantasy season has a breakout rookie, and Bijan Robinson looks like that candidate. Though untested, his skill set and expected role in the Falcons’ offense create significant buzz.

Historical Trends for the 1st Overall Pick

Running Back Dominance in History

For years, running backs were the dominant choice for 1st overall picks. This is due to their dual-role potential and scarcity at the top of the position. Players like LaDainian Tomlinson and Adrian Peterson became legendary for their consistency and league-winning performances.

Shifts in PPR Formats

With trends leaning toward PPR scoring, wide receivers have gained value in the 1st pick conversation. Modern players like Cooper Kupp and Davante Adams have frequently entered discussions because of their reliability and sheer volume of targets.

Risks vs. Rewards

The 1st pick doesn’t always lead to success. Injuries, underperformances, and team struggles can derail even the most promising pick. Examining past disappointments like Todd Gurley in 2019 (after his phenomenal 2018 season) serves as a reminder to balance upside with risk.

Expert Tips for Maximizing the 1st Pick

Be Flexible and Adaptable

Draft strategies aren’t one-size-fits-all. Depending on league settings, format (PPR vs. standard scoring), and the players available, you may need to pivot your initial plan. Research your league’s scoring system and prioritize accordingly.

Build Around Your Superstar

After selecting your 1st pick, carefully craft the rest of your team. Surround your superstar with complementary assets — if you pick a running back first, focus on snagging elite wide receivers or a top-tier quarterback in the next rounds.

Gain an Edge in Fantasy
Get insights that give you a competitive edge with this guide. See the Guide >>>

Monitor Reports and Updates

NFL rosters change constantly, so stay updated on injury reports, training camp buzz, and team depth charts to reinforce your decision.

Diversify Your Player Pool

If you’re managing multiple leagues, don’t rely on the same player as your first pick in all drafts. Diversification mitigates risk and increases your chances of success across leagues.

Quick Tips for 1st Pick Success

• Focus on health history and durability.

• Favor players with stable team situations and coaching staffs.

• Consider talent over hype to avoid overvalued players.

• Leverage mock drafts to test various scenarios.

The Impact of Choosing the Perfect 1st Pick

Your 1st pick impacts everything, from your weekly floor to your long-term playoff prospects. A well-designed strategy empowers you to stay ahead, neutralize competitors' advantages, and field a consistent lineup. Ultimately, the 1st pick is your opportunity to shine, and selecting wisely makes championship dreams attainable.

With all this information, you're armed with the knowledge to dominate your fantasy league in the upcoming season. Choose a player who fits your strategy, balances risk and reward, and delivers value every single week. The right 1st pick sets the stage for greatness — now it's up to you to execute.

Advanced Strategies to Maximize Your 1st Pick

Understanding Positional Tiers

A winning strategy often involves understanding the concept of positional tiers. This means grouping players based on their likely output rather than solely relying on rankings. For your first pick, knowing which tier a player belongs to can make or break your roster foundation.

• Why Tiers Matter: Instead of focusing on picking "the best player," positional tiers show you when talent levels drop off. For example, the difference between an elite tier running back and the next tier can be substantial, often making an RB the logical first pick.

• Tier-Based Drafting Strategy: If your first pick belongs to a deep positional tier—like wide receiver in recent seasons—consider selecting a player from a thinner tier (like running back) to balance roster makeup in later rounds.

Zero-RB and Modified Strategies

Fantasy football has evolved with experimental strategies like Zero-RB. Understanding these options can highlight how to capitalize on your draft position.

• Zero-RB Strategy: Some managers fade running backs early and target elite WRs or even a TE with high upside. For instance, starting with a pick like Justin Jefferson can allow freedom to stack second-round WRs or a QB.

• Modified Zero-RB: This variation focuses on grabbing one elite RB (potentially with your 1st pick) and then focusing entirely on other positions in subsequent rounds.

Value Over Replacement Player (VORP)

Utilizing VORP helps you understand value gaps between your first selected player and the next viable option at that position.

• High VORP Players for Round One: Based on historical data, players like Christian McCaffrey or Justin Jefferson produce significantly more points compared to average starters at their positions, making them ideal first picks.

• VORP as a Draft Guide: Calculate the value gap each time you're on the clock. This ensures you're always securing an asset whose drop-off exceeds other options.

All-in-One Fantasy Guide
Ready to dominate your league? Get 1317 tips to do just that. Check It Out >>>

Psychological Dynamics of Drafting First

Confidence and Intimidation

The first pick establishes a powerful starting point, which can work in your favor psychologically. Other managers often worry about counter-picking to your strengths, giving you more freedom in the draft.

• Creating Pressure: A strong pick like Jefferson, paired with a smart second-round choice, can influence other managers to overdraft WRs or RBs. Capitalize on this trend by focusing on neglected positions yourself.

• Overcoming Doubt: Psychologically, the first pick may put pressure on you to deliver perfection. Avoid overthinking—sometimes the simplest, safest pick is the best choice.

Reading the Room

Draft day isn’t just about your roster; it’s about recognizing other managers’ tendencies. Pay attention to your league-mates’ picks and adjust accordingly.

• Identify Trends: Early quarterback runs or unpredictable picks may open opportunities to steal value.

• Leverage Mock Drafts: Participating in mock drafts can help prepare you for outlier scenarios, such as someone reaching for a quarterback with the second pick.

Avoid Falling Into Biases

Recency bias (emphasizing last season’s performances) and perceived “upside” can skew decisions. Anchoring your pick to data and proven players limits errors.

Role of Analytics in Draft Day Decisions

Predictive Analytics and Projections

Fantasy football is increasingly driven by data. Using analytics for projections can help you refine your decision-making process for that pivotal pick.

• Player Metrics: Look at metrics such as target share for WRs, rushing opportunities for RBs, and red-zone usage for all players.

• Scoring Projections: Evaluate players based on projected point totals for your league format. Not all players perform equally across standard and PPR leagues.

Advanced Stats to Consider

Certain advanced metrics can separate good from great draft picks. These include:

• Yards-Per-Touch: Helps predict efficiency for RBs and WRs.

• Expected Points (xP): Measures scoring based on play context, crucial for identifying consistent players.

• Team Offensive Scheme: High-scoring offenses such as Kansas City or San Francisco boost player opportunities, adding value to stars like Travis Kelce or McCaffrey.

Using Draft Software and Tools

Many managers use tools like draft simulators or live-tracking apps to stay ahead.

• Auto-Tracking Tools: Keep track of player availability and positional runs during the draft to prevent being caught off guard.

• AI Assistants: These tools can help suggest value picks based on trends, though it’s important to trust your gut when conflicting advice arises.

Handling Unexpected Scenarios During the Draft

Managing the Snake Format Combo Picks

Picking first in a snake draft means having two rapid-fire picks in Rounds 2 and 3. Always account for these scenarios.

• Balanced Targeting: After selecting an elite RB first, aim to grab strong WR options like CeeDee Lamb or an early QB like Jalen Hurts during the comeback swing.

• Exploit Positional Trends: If there’s a late run on QBs in Round 2, consider going contrarian and stacking RBs and WRs instead.

Dealing With Injury News

Sometimes, draft injuries or breaking news can affect your top choice. Always be flexible and prepared to pivot.

• Mid-Draft Adjustments: Draft backups or handcuffs (e.g., Alexander Mattison if you pick McCaffrey) to cover injury risk.

• Live Updates: Keep Twitter or news apps handy for up-to-the-minute reports.

Drafting Against Contrarian Managers

If your league mates love unpredictable strategies, you might find top-ranked players falling to you later. Avoid overreacting and stick to your tier system.

Tips for Handling Surprise Picks:

• Don’t reach for players just because others have. Stay focused on value.

• Adapt by stockpiling areas that end up light in depth due to unusual drafting trends.

Not sure when to trade or hold? Find out the perfect timing for fantasy football trades in this article right here. >>>

Building a Winner After Your 1st Pick

The 1st pick is the heart of your team, but your draft success depends on the supporting cast. Look for opportunities to pair your first-rounder with players who complement their strengths.

Stack Synergies

Stacking a QB with your top WR or TE can amplify your scoring potential.

• Examples: Drafting Jefferson first? Target Kirk Cousins later.

• Upside: While team dependency can be risky, scoring twice on the same offense has massive weekly upside.

FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

1. What is the most important factor when deciding on the first pick in fantasy football?

The most important factor is choosing a player with a combination of high consistency, durability, and upside in their statistical output. Thorough research on player performance and trends is crucial to making an optimal decision.

2. Should I always draft a running back with my first overall pick?

Not necessarily. Historically, running backs have been favored, but in PPR formats, elite wide receivers like Justin Jefferson or Cooper Kupp can provide better long-term value and consistency.

3. How do I handle positional scarcity with the first pick?

Use positional tiers to understand depth at each position. Running backs often fall into a scarce category, so it may be wise to secure an elite one early if the value aligns.

4. Should league scoring format influence my first pick?

Yes, league scoring formats like PPR, standard, or superflex should strongly influence your decision. For example, PPR formats increase the value of pass-catching players, while superflex leagues elevate quarterbacks.

5. Can I pick a quarterback first overall?

It depends on your league. While quarterbacks usually don’t go first in standard leagues due to depth, in superflex leagues where you can start two QBs, a player like Patrick Mahomes could be justifiable.

6. Is selecting a rookie with the first pick a good idea?

Rookies are generally a risky first-pick option. However, rare prospects with guaranteed workloads, such as Bijan Robinson this season, may be worth considering in certain situations.

Searching for the ultimate team name? Here’s 5971 options without player names! >>>

7. Are injury-prone players a bad choice for the first pick?

Players with injury histories carry higher risks, but they could still be valuable if they’ve historically performed at an elite level when healthy. Always weigh their upside against potential downtime.

8. How do I evaluate consistency for the first pick?

Look at game logs from previous seasons to see how often a player delivers high-level performances. Metrics like points per game and their involvement in the offense also signal consistency.

9. How far ahead should I plan my picks after selecting first?

Having a rough plan for the next two to three rounds is smart. Think about positional balance and avoid overloading one position early in favor of a well-rounded team.

10. Can the first pick alone win my fantasy league?

No, the first pick sets the foundation but does not guarantee success. Building a strong and balanced team throughout the draft is essential for long-term victories.

11. Is mock drafting helpful for deciding the first pick strategy?

Absolutely. Mock drafts allow you to simulate various scenarios, helping you understand how players are valued and how to tailor your draft strategy accordingly.

12. What is the “best player available” (BPA) strategy, and is it good for the first pick?

The BPA strategy involves picking the most talented player regardless of position. For the first pick, this often works well since you want the most reliable, high-impact player on your roster.

13. How do I deal with early draft anxiety?

Preparation is key. Familiarize yourself with rankings, tiers, and your league’s scoring system to feel confident. Mock drafting also helps reduce any last-minute nerves.

14. What are positional tiers, and why are they important for the draft?

Positional tiers group players with similar value within a position. They help identify when talent drop-offs occur, so you can prioritize picks strategically.

15. Can I trade my first pick for multiple later-round picks?

Some leagues allow this. Trading the first pick can work if you receive significant value in return, but this strategy adds risk as it relies on drafting depth over an elite asset.

16. What should I do if my preferred player is ruled out before the draft?

Always prepare contingency plans. Have a shortlist of options for the first pick in case unexpected injury news or depth chart changes occur before your draft.

17. How can I counter unexpected draft trends after my first pick?

Stay flexible. If your league goes heavy on one position early, capitalize by choosing other high-value positions that may be neglected.

Perfect Your Fantasy Draft
Draft smarter, trade better, and play stronger with these pro tips! Start Here >>>

18. Should I prioritize high-upside or consistent players with my first pick?

It depends on your risk tolerance. For the first pick, consistency generally outweighs upside since stability builds a strong foundation for your team.

19. Are wide receivers safer than running backs with the first pick?

Yes, especially in PPR formats. Wide receivers typically have longer careers and lower injury risk compared to running backs, making them a safer option.

20. How does bye week scheduling impact the first pick?

The first pick’s bye week is less critical since you should have time to build depth and plan around it for that single week later in the season.

21. Is stacking team players a smart strategy after my first pick?

Stacking can be a high-upside strategy. For example, if you select Justin Jefferson first, grabbing Kirk Cousins later in the draft can maximize scoring through touchdowns.

22. How do I use analytics to make the first pick?

Focus on advanced metrics like target share, yards after contact, and touchdown efficiency. These data points provide insights into a player's ability to maintain elite production.

23. Should I consider team context when selecting the first pick?

Yes. Look for players in high-scoring offenses or with stable coaching staffs and quarterback situations, as they are more likely to produce consistently.

24. What are the risks of overthinking the first pick?

Overanalyzing can lead to hesitation or passing on obvious choices. Trust the research, make a confident decision, and move forward with your draft strategy.

Get the insights you need to trade wisely with 3529 expert tips. >>>

25. Can a defense or kicker be drafted first overall?

No. Defenses and kickers rarely justify early picks as their scoring variability and replacement value are far lower than skill positions like RB, WR, or QB.

26. Can my first pick help dictate my entire draft strategy?

Yes. Your choice can determine whether you adopt strategies like Zero-RB, balanced rosters, or positional dominance throughout the draft process.

27. How do positional runs impact the value of my first pick?

Positional runs during the draft can increase the importance of your chosen position. For example, a shortage of RBs by Round 2 could amplify the value of securing an early elite RB.

28. Should I focus on workload or efficiency when choosing my first pick?

Both are essential, but prioritizing players with a high workload ensures you’re getting consistent opportunities for scoring, which is vital for early picks.

29. Is there an optimal way to prepare for drafting first?

Yes, preparation includes researching player stats, participating in mock drafts, understanding league scoring settings, and crafting contingency plans for unexpected scenarios.

30. Can selecting the wrong first pick ruin my season?

While it can create challenges, a single misstep with the first pick is recoverable. Smart trades, waiver pickups, and midseason strategies can help salvage your league.

Related Posts:

Top-Tier Fantasy Strategies
Use these tried-and-tested strategies to enhance your fantasy game. Learn How >>>

Looking for the ultimate edge in your league? Access 3529 trade tips for fantasy football dominance by clicking here. >>>

Discover fun team names that honor NFL stars! Get ideas here now >>>

Please note

This website (the “Blog”) is published and provided for informational and entertainment purposes only!

The information in the Blog constitutes the content creator’s own opinions (and any guest bloggers posting from time to time) and it should not be regarded as a description of any services provided by any company!

When it comes to matters of health, always consult with a trained medical professional – never rely solely on digital information. Taking into account your individual situation will help you make the best decisions for your own wellbeing!

The Blog serves as an informative resource, but should never be used to diagnose or treat a medical condition. When it comes to your health, always consult with a qualified doctor for the best advice and care tailored specifically for you!

The Blog and the materials and information it contains are not intended to, and do not constitute, medical or other health advice or any medical product advice or diagnosis and should not be used as such. You should always consult with a qualified physician or health professional about your specific circumstances!

Also the opinions expressed in the Blog are for general informational purposes only and are not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual or on any specific security or investment product or loan, loans, credit, insurance or any other financial product or transaction. It is only intended to provide education about the financial industry. The views reflected in the commentary are subject to change at any time without notice!

Nothing on this Blog constitutes investment advice, performance data or any recommendation that any security, portfolio of securities, investment product, transaction or investment strategy, loan, loans, credit, insurance or any other financial instrument or transaction is suitable for any specific person!

From reading this Blog we cannot assess anything about your personal circumstances, your finances, or your goals and objectives, all of which are unique to you, so any opinions or information contained on this Blog are just that – an opinion or information!

You should not use this Blog to make financial decisions and we highly recommend you seek professional advice from someone who is authorized to provide investment advice!

Any indices referenced for comparison are unmanaged and cannot be invested into directly.  Investments in securities involve the risk of loss. Past performance is no guarantee of future results!

This Blog contains links to other websites (which may include message boards or forums). We are not responsible for the privacy practices or the content of such sites. Please understand that any information that is disclosed in these areas becomes public information. We have no control over its use and you should exercise caution when deciding to disclose your personal information!

Conclusion

Optimize your pick variety post-draft. If you pick an ultra-reliable player like Ekeler first, you can afford to take higher-risk, higher-upside candidates later, such as rookies or breakout WRs.

With these advanced strategies in hand, you’re ready to dominate your fantasy football league with not just a strong 1st pick—but a comprehensive game plan that ensures long-term success.